Operations

How to tell whether your dealer teams are performing or just coasting

“Everyone says they are doing well”

You ask every dealer or branch head how the month went. Every one of them says it went well. The sales total is up a little, or down a little for reasons that sound sensible: a festival fell late, a competitor ran a scheme, the rains came early.

You have no way to test any of these explanations. So you praise everyone equally, or you praise whoever speaks best on the review call. Neither is management. It is guessing with a polite tone.

What it costs

Take a distributor with 40 dealers and a monthly secondary-sales target of ₹8 crore across the network. Suppose ten dealers are doing well because of strong local relationships, and ten are coasting on an old customer base that buys without being chased. Both groups hit roughly the same number in a good month, so the total gives no warning.

Then a competitor moves into the territories of the coasting group. Because nobody was measuring effort, only outcome, the first signal is a missed target two months later. If those ten dealers account for ₹2 crore of the monthly figure and they lose a quarter of it before you react, that is ₹50 lakh a month gone before the first serious conversation about it.

The second cost is quieter. People who work hard get the same recognition as those who do not. Your best sales executives notice first, and they are the ones who leave.

Why it happens

Sales totals measure results, and results lag behaviour. A dealer who stopped visiting retailers in week two does not show up in the numbers until week eight.

Most networks also compare dealers against the average. The average blends large territories and small ones, so a dealer in a strong market looks good for doing very little, and a dealer in a hard market looks weak for doing a great deal.

Finally, the data sits in different places. Orders come on WhatsApp, targets live in a spreadsheet at head office, and visit reports, if they exist, are in a field manager’s notebook. Nobody can put them side by side.

What changes it

Start with a short list of leading measures that you can define in one sentence each. For a dealer network these are usually:

  • How many active retailers the dealer billed this month, against how many are on the books
  • How quickly new enquiries and orders get a response
  • How many customers who bought last quarter were contacted again
  • How many outlets each field person visited, against plan

Then compare like with like. Group dealers by territory size and potential, and compare each against the best in its group and against its own last quarter. A dealer improving steadily in a hard territory deserves a different conversation from one sliding in an easy one.

Finally, fix a rhythm. A weekly twenty-minute review of four or five measures catches a dip in week two. A monthly review of sales totals catches it in week eight, which is the difference between a conversation and a recovery plan.

Systems help once the definitions are agreed: the measures can be pulled from orders and visit records automatically, rather than typed into a sheet on Friday evening. But automating a measure nobody agreed on only produces a faster argument.

What this does not fix

Measuring activity does not make people competent. If a dealer is weak because of cash flow, a bad warehouse or a poor local team, the numbers show the symptom and nothing else. Someone still has to visit, ask and decide. And no outside comparison is worth much unless the businesses being compared are genuinely similar to yours, so be sceptical of any benchmark that does not say who is in it.

If you want to see how a network like this is run day to day, this is the work DealerPlus does under control.