“My biggest dealer is not my best dealer”
You have 150 dealers. The ranking you look at each month is by sales. The top ten get your attention, the festival gifts and the visits. But your accounts head mentions, almost in passing, that three of the top ten pay late, return a lot of goods and take the largest discounts. You realise you do not actually know which dealers make you money.
What it costs
A hypothetical comparison. Dealer A buys ₹40 lakh a year at a 6 per cent margin to you, pays in 25 days, and returns almost nothing. Dealer B buys ₹60 lakh at the same list price but takes extra discounts that cut your margin to 3 per cent, pays in 70 days and returns goods worth ₹2 lakh.
Dealer A gives you ₹2.4 lakh of margin. Dealer B gives you ₹1.8 lakh before returns, and less once you subtract ₹2 lakh of returned goods handled twice and the cost of carrying ₹60 lakh a year of receivables for about 45 extra days: around ₹90,000 at 12 per cent. Dealer B is larger and worth less. In a sales ranking, B comes first.
Why it happens
Sales is the number everybody already has. Margin, payment time, returns and service cost sit in different places, and nobody has put them together. Dealers also differ in territory, size and product mix, so comparing raw numbers is unfair in both directions: a dealer in a small town may be doing very well relative to the opportunity.
Without a fair comparison, owners rely on relationships and recent conversations. The dealer who calls most often gets the most attention, whether or not the business deserves it.
What changes it
Choose a small set of measures that together describe a dealer’s value to you. A good starting set:
- Sales and growth over the last twelve months.
- Margin after discounts and schemes.
- Days to pay and the amount overdue.
- Returns and claims as a share of sales.
- Spread of product range sold, not only the fast lines.
- Share of the dealer’s territory you appear to be reaching, where you can estimate it.
Compare dealers against their peers, grouped by size or territory, not against the whole network. A dealer is then judged against the dealers in a comparable position.
Agree what happens at each level. Strong performers get investment: stock priority, joint planning, targeted support. Middle performers get a clear plan with a three-month review. Weak performers are told the numbers and given a choice: improve, change terms or part ways. The decision rights matter: someone must be accountable for acting, and it should not rest with the salesperson who manages the relationship alone.
Doing this by spreadsheet is possible for 30 dealers and painful for 150. Once sales, payments and returns live in one record, a monthly scorecard can be produced without a week of assembly, and trends become visible early. Analysis tools can help find patterns, but the measures and the response must be chosen by you.
Begin with your top twenty dealers and only four measures. A one-page comparison, discussed with the regional heads, often changes who gets attention within a single meeting, and it shows quickly which measures are hard to collect and need better records.
What this does not fix
A scorecard measures what is recorded; it does not capture a dealer’s local reputation, goodwill or strategic value in a new market. Comparison data is internal, so it will not tell you how you stand against competitors’ networks. And a dealer judged unfairly by a poor measure will leave. Share the measures with dealers openly.
If you plan to add dealers, test what the network and your own team can carry using the dealer expansion model.